Please pardon our dust as we work to create a list of all of the sheriff's that worked at or lived in the old sheriff's house. If you would like to contribute to this page please contact us at: info at oldsheriffshouse.org.
H.G. Bliss 1880 - 1884
.
R.H. Wells 1884 - 1888
.
A.M. Turner 1888 - 1892
.
Charles H. Friedricks 1892 - 1894
.
Benjamin F. Hayes 1894 - 1898
.
George Lawrence 1898 - 1902
.
Charles J. Daugherty 1902 - 1906
.
Fred S. Carter 1906 - 1908
.
Tom Grant 1908 - 1914
.
Henry Whitaker 1914 - 1917
.
Lewis E. Barnes 1917 - 1920
.
William H. Olds 1920 - 1924
.
Benjamin Strong 1924 - 1928
.
Joseph P. Kyle 1928 - 1930
.
Roy "Doc" Holley 1930 - 1933
Roy Holley served as Lake County's 31st Sheriff and was tragically gunned down while trying to arrest the Ross Township Madman.
Andrew Hoffman 1933 - Acting
.
Lillian Holley 1933 - 1934
Lillian Holley accepted the position as Lake County Sheriff after her husband Roy Holley was killed on January 16th, 1933.